Review / Response to Calestous Juma’s book: The New Harvest

I love the cover of this book as it simply illustrates how important agriculture is to this continent.

I must admit that at first I was a bit turned off by Calestous Juma’s The New Harvest: Agricultural Innovations in Africa, not because it wasn’t well written and researched but because I was expecting more of a micro focus on African agricultural success over another macro-level development book. Having already read numerous books and articles from Collier, Easterly, Rodrick, and others I’d pretty much heard the story of “infrastructure, education, and governance” repeated enough. But upon revisiting the book a bit later, I realized that it is the African focus and, specifically, the application of examples from other countries and how they would apply to many nations in Africa that makes the book unique and worthwhile.

As I said, Juma doesn’t stray from the usual cadence heard from other economic development specialists, even a short glace at the chapter titles like “Enabling Infrastructure,” “Human Capacity,” “Entrepreneurship,” and “Governing Innovation” demonstrates this. His strength is in the application of these concepts to an African setting, and, in some cases, even the more localized settings of specific countries or regions.

It’s easy for a writer to come out and say that a country needs to build infrastructure in order to improve the economy, because that’s somewhat of a no duh statement. But Juma looks at specific examples of road construction in Africa as well as drawing from development examples from China and finds that while large highways are useful for the transportation of goods and natural resources, it is lower-quality rural roads which provide the greatest jump in GDP. He found, when using examples of agricultural development in China, that for every yaun invested in rural roads it would generate 1.57 yaun in agricultural GDP. Even more exciting, the same yaun would yield over 5 yaun in nonfarm GDP. Because of the incredibly low quality of African rural roads, Juma proposes that an equal or greater benefit would be found if the same infrastructural development were applied to African nations.

In the area of education, Juma discusses both capacity building in the knowledge and education of rural farmers, but also stresses the need for research institutions, like universities, which are funded by the governments and have ties to the private sector for development of African-specific innovations. The idea is that the western world isn’t going to do the research necessary to alleviate African-specific problems; western solutions will always be more applicable in the western world and don’t always translate correctly. Again, using China and other south-eastern countries, Juma discusses how the governments made a switch from a more government-controlled research mandate to a government which encourages universities to do the research and to work with the private sector in the application phase. Many of the innovations which arose in the decades which followed solved a number of agricultural problems which were Asian specific.

Juma is a major proponent of regional economic partnerships, which open up trade and tend to lead to greater agricultural diversity and less famines, and he believes these groups must be promoted and strengthened. Also, he argues that governments must work to active promote the spread of innovations which are already available in the countries but many rural farmers don’t use because of lack of knowledge of the existence, lack of knowledge on how to employ the innovations, and lack of access to financing.

Applications like these make the book stand out as a useful resource for anyone looking into development policy, particularly in the African Agricultural Sector. I would like to see more African-specific examples though. There is a nice section on the development of airports in Mali, a landlocked country which has had export problems because of unrest in neighboring countries, but these examples are few and far between. Overall, I do think it’s a worthwhile read and one which has a sort of applied macro-economic approach to agricultural development that could make an impact in the lives of poor farmers around the continent.

*Update: Excerpts from the book, including the full text of Chapters 1 & 7) can be found at  http://www.belfercenter.org/global/.

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Review / Response to Calestous Juma’s book: The New Harvest

  1. Great review of “The New Harvest”, possibly the first by a student. The focus is on innovation and in the micro-economics domain. You are right that we have seen enough on the macro-economic front. I hope other students will read and do more case studies of what is happening on ground in Africa, of which there is a lot.

    • Thank you for the comment. As I said, I did really enjoy the book and like how the principles were applied to innovations in Africa. I do highly recommend it to anyone currently studying development and agriculture related to Africa or anyone currently doing African Ag work/policy now. And, yes, I too hope more on-the-ground research is conducted. I’ll leave that to others though as I’m more on the project implementation path.

  2. Yes, we need a lot more people working on implementation. Power to you! We have shipped 8,000 copies of the book to various locations in Africa with the hope that it will inspire more people to take the pragmatic road.

    • That’s also very good to hear, because, as I’m sure you know, many of the Ex-Pat workers and English-Speaking professionals here tend to seek out the few English book stores and buy whatever development books are on the shelf. When I leave Kisangani, DRC in a few weeks I’m leaving my copy with a Congolese Agricultural Trainer who actually prefers to read in English over French. I’m sure it will be enlightening for him. Thank you again for the reply and have a Happy Easter.

  3. We are also working on making the whole book available online in the near future. We have excerpts at http://www.belfercenter.org/global/. I am also interested in doing other language editions but wanted to have the English version take off first. I am certain to respond to your challenge to have more cases in next editions as well. Are you following the work by Worldwatch Institute? They have release a report with a lot of examples. Our works complement each other. Since you are in DRC I will connect you with Congolese colleagues working in international organizations seeking to get more work done on the ground. Keep up the good work and dedication despite malaria threats.

  4. African Agriculture is at crossroads. I believe the book address pertinent issues at macro-level needed to spur agriculture. I can speak much for Kenya where agriculture has been neglected in the past by policy makers. The sector does not contribute much th country’s GDP as it used to a decade ago. I have given a copy of the book to the head of the agriculture ministry hoping to change things around !

  5. Pingback: why I blog/tweet « haba na haba

  6. Pingback: Harvard – Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs – Belfer In The News » Blog Archive » Review/Response to CALESTOUS JUMA’s book, The New Harvest

  7. Pingback: Review/Response to CALESTOUS JUMA's book, The New Harvest | Belfer In The News

  8. Pingback: Review/Response to CALESTOUS JUMA's book, The New Harvest | Belfer In The News

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s